Background: End colostomy rates following colorectal resection vary across institutions in high-income settings, being influenced by patient, disease, surgeon and system factors. This study aimed to assess global variation in end colostomy rates after left-sided colorectal resection. Methods: This study comprised an analysis of GlobalSurg-1 and -2 international, prospective, observational cohort studies (2014, 2016), including consecutive adult patients undergoing elective or emergency left-sided colorectal resection within discrete 2-week windows. Countries were grouped into high-, middle- and low-income tertiles according to the United Nations Human Development Index (HDI). Factors associated with colostomy formation versus primary anastomosis were explored using a multilevel, multivariable logistic regression model. Results: In total, 1635 patients from 242 hospitals in 57 countries undergoing left-sided colorectal resection were included: 113 (6·9 per cent) from low-HDI, 254 (15·5 per cent) from middle-HDI and 1268 (77·6 per cent) from high-HDI countries. There was a higher proportion of patients with perforated disease (57·5, 40·9 and 35·4 per cent; P < 0·001) and subsequent use of end colostomy (52·2, 24·8 and 18·9 per cent; P < 0·001) in low- compared with middle- and high-HDI settings. The association with colostomy use in low-HDI settings persisted (odds ratio (OR) 3·20, 95 per cent c.i. 1·35 to 7·57; P = 0·008) after risk adjustment for malignant disease (OR 2·34, 1·65 to 3·32; P < 0·001), emergency surgery (OR 4·08, 2·73 to 6·10; P < 0·001), time to operation at least 48 h (OR 1·99, 1·28 to 3·09; P = 0·002) and disease perforation (OR 4·00, 2·81 to 5·69; P < 0·001). Conclusion: Global differences existed in the proportion of patients receiving end stomas after left-sided colorectal resection based on income, which went beyond case mix alone.
Global variation in anastomosis and end colostomy formation following left-sided colorectal resection / Glasbey JC, Adisa AO, Costas-Chavarri A, Qureshi AU, Allen-Ingabire JC, Salem HK, Kojo ATT, Tabiri S, Nepogodiev D, Lilford RJ, Harrison EM, Pinkney TD, Smart N, Bhangu A, Verjee A, Runigamugabo E, Glasbey J, Bhangu A, Ademuyiwa AO, Adisa AO, Aguilera ML, Altamini A, Alexander P, Al-Saqqa SW, Borda-Luque G, Cornick J, Costas-Chavarri A, Drake TM, Fergusson SJ, Fitzgerald JE, Glasbey J, Ingabire JCA, Ismaïl L, Jaffry Z, Salem HK, Khatri C, Kirby A, Kojo ATT, Lapitan MC, Lilford R, Mihaljevic AL, Mohan M, Morton D, Mutabazi AZ, Nepogodiev D, Ntirenganya F, Ots R, Pata F, Pinkney T, Poškus T, Qureshi AU, la Medina AR, Rayne S, Recinos G, Søreide K, Shaw CA, Shu S, Spence R, Smart N, Tabiri S, Lilford R, Morton D, Harrison EM, Bhangu A, Khatri C, Gobin N, Freitas AV, Hall N, Kim SH, Negida A, Khairy H, Jaffry Z, Chapman SJ, Arnaud AP, Tabiri S, Recinos G, Manipal CE, Mohan M, Amandito R, Shawki M, Hanrahan M, Pata F, Zilinskas J, Roslani AC, Goh CC, Ademuyiwa AO, Irwin G, Shu S, Luque L, Shiwani H, Altamimi A, Alsaggaf MU, Fergusson SJ, Spence R, Rayne S, Jeyakumar J, Cengiz Y, Raptis DA, Glasbey JC, Modolo MM, Iyer D, King S, Arthur T, Nahar SN, Waterman A, Ismaïl L, Walsh M, Agarwal A, Zani A, Firdouse M, Rouse T, Liu Q, Correa JC, Salem HK, Talving P, Worku M, Arnaud A, Tabiri S, Kalles V, Aguilera ML, Recinos G, Kumar B, Kumar S, Amandito R, Quek R, Pata F, Ansaloni L, Altibi A, Venskutonis D, Zilinskas J, Poskus T, Whitaker J, Msosa V, Tew YY, Farrugia A, Borg E, la Medina AR, Bentounsi Z, Ademuyiwa AO, Søreide K, Gala T, Al-Slaibi I, Tahboub H, Alser OH, Romani D, Shu S, Major P, Mironescu A, Bratu M, Kourdouli A, Ndajiwo A, Altwijri A, Alsaggaf MU, Gudal A, Jubran AF, Seisay S, Lieske B, Rayne S, Spence R, Ortega I, Jeyakumar J, Senanayake KJ, Abdulbagi O, Cengiz Y, Raptis D, Altinel Y, Kong C, Teasdale E, Irwin G, Stoddart M, Kabariti R, Suresh S, Gash K, Narayanan R, Maimbo M, Fermani C, Balmaceda R, Modolo MM, Macdermid E, Gobin N, Chenn R, Yong CO, Edye M, Jarmin M, D'amours SK, Iyer D, Youssef D, Phillips N, Brown J, George R, Koh C, Warren O, Hanley I, Dickfos M, Nawara C, Öfner D, Primavesi F, Mitul AR, Mahmud K, Hussain M, Hakim H, Kumar T, Oosterkamp A, Assouto PA, Lawani I, Souaibou YI, Tun AK, Chong CL, Devadasar GH, Chong CL, Qadir MRM, Aung KP, Yeo LS, Chong CL, Castillo VDP, Munhoz MM, Moreira G, De Castro Segundo LCB, Ferreira SAK, Careta MC, Kim SB, De Sousa AV, Cury ADL, Miguel GPS, De Freitas AVC, Guasti BPSJ, Vianna P, Felipe CO, Laufer LAV, Altoe F, Da Silva LA, Pimenta ML, Giuriato TF, Morais PAB, Araujo JSLR, Menegussi J, Leal M, de Lima CVB, Tatagiba LS, Leal A, Dos Santos DV, Fraga GP, Simoes RL, Stock S, Nigo S, Kabba J, Ngwa TE, Brown J, King S, Zani A, Azzie G, Firdouse M, Kushwaha S, Agarwal A, Bailey K, Cameron B, Livingston M, Horobjowsky A, Deckelbaum DL, Razek T, Marinkovic B, Grasset E, D'aguzan N, Grasset E, Jimenez J, Macchiavello R, Zhang Z, Guo W, Oh J, Zheng F, Montes I, Sierra S, Mendez M, Villegas MI, Arango MCM, Mendoza I, Naranjo Aristizã Bal FA, Botero JAM, Riaza VMQ, Restrepo J, Morales C, Arango MCM, Cruz H, Munera A, Arango MCM, Karlo R, Domini E, Mihanovic J, Radic M, Zamarin K, Pezelj N, Hache-Marliere M, Lemaire SB, Rivas R, Khyrallh A, Hassan A, Shimy G, Baky Fahmy MA, Nabawi A, Elfil M, Ghoneem M, Gohar MEAM, Asal M, Abdelkader M, Gomah M, Rashwan H, Karkeet M, Gomaa A, Hasan A, Elgebaly A, Saleh O, Fattah AA, Gouda A, Elshafay AE, Gharib A, Menshawy A, Hanafy M, Al-Mallah A, Abdulgawad M, Baheeg M, Alhendy M, AbdelFattah I, Kenibar A, Osman O, Gemeah M, Mohammed A, Adel A, Gharib A, Mohammed A, Sayed A, Abozaid M, Kotb AHE, Ata AAA, Nasr M, Alkammash A, Saeed M, El Hamid NA, Attia AM, El Galeel AA, Elbanby E, El-Dien KS, Hantour U, Alahmady O, Mansour B, Elkorashy AM, Taha EMS, Lasheen KT, Elkolaly SS, Abdel-Wahab NYE, Abozyed MAF, Adel A, Saeed AM, El Sayed GS, Youssif JH, Ahmed SM, El-Shahat NS, Khedr AEH, Elsebaaye AO, Elzayat M, Abdelraheim M, Elzayat I, Warda M, El Deen KN, Elnemr AE, Salah O, Abbas M, Rashad M, Elzayyat I, Hemeda D, Tawfik G, Salama M, Khaled H, Seisa M, Elshaer K, Hussein A, Elkhadrawi M, Afifi AM, Ebrahim OS, Metwally MM, Elmelegy R, Elsawahly DME, Safa H, Nofal E, Elbermawy M, Ghazy AA, Samih H, Abdelgelil A, Abdelghany S, El Kholy A, Aboraya M, Elkady F, Salma M, Samy S, Fakher R, Aboarab A, Samir A, Sakr A, Haroun A, Al-Aarag AA, Elkholy A, Elshanwany S, Ghanem E, Tammam A, Hammad AM, El Shoura Y, El Ashal G, Khairy H, Antar S, Mehrez S, Abdelshafy M, Hamad MGM, Hosh M, Abdallah E, Magdy B, Alzayat T, Gamaly E, Elfeki H, Abouzahra A, Elsheikh S, Elgendy FI, El-Salam FA, Seifelnasr O, Ammar M, Eysa A, Sadek A, Toeema AG, Nasr A, Abuseif M, Zidan H, Barakat SAE, Elsayed N, Elrasoul YA, Elkelany A, Ammar MS, Mustafa MA, Hegazy Y, Etman M, Saad S, Alrahawy M, Raslan A, Morsi M, Rslan A, Sabry A, Elwakil H, Shaker H, Zidan H, Abd-Elrasoul Y, Elkelany A, El-Kashef H, Shaalan M, Tarek A, Elwan A, Nayel AR, Seif M, Elwan A, Emadeldin D, Ghonaim MA, Almallah A, Fouad A, Sayma EA, Elbatahgy A, El-Ma'doul AS, Mosad A, Tolba H, Elsorogy DEAA, Mostafa HA, Omar AA, El Hameed OSA, Lasheen A, El Salam YA, Morsi A, Ismail M, El-Badawy HA, Amer MA, Elkelany A, Elkelany A, El-Hamouly AS, Attallah NA, Mosalum O, Afandy A, Mokhtar A, Abouelnasr A, Ayad S, Shaker R, Sakr R, Shaker R, Amreia M, Elsobky S, Mustafa M, El Magd AA, Marey A, Hafez AT, Zalabia MF, Mohamed MM, Fadel A, Ahmed EA, Ali A, Alwafai MG, Dwydar A, Kharsa S, Mamdouh E, El-Sheemy H, AlYoussef I, Aly AK, Aldalaq A, Alnawam E, Alkhabbaz D, Saad M, Hussein S, Elazayem AA, Meshref A, Elashmawy M, Mousa M, Nashaat A, Ghanem S, Elsayed ZM, Elwaey A, Elkadsh I, Darweesh M, Mohameden A, Hafez M, Badr A, Badwy A, El Slam MA, Elazoul M, Al-Nahrawi S, Eldamaty L, Nada F, Ameen M, Hagar A, Elsehimy M, Aboraya M, Dawoud H, El Mesery S, El Gendy A, Abdelkareem A, Marey AS, Allam M, Shehata S, Abozeid K, Elshobary M, Fahiem A, Sarsik S, Hashish A, Zidan M, Hashish M, Aql S, Elhendawy AOA, Husseini M, Kasem E, Gheith A, Elfouly Y, Soliman AR, Ibrahim Y, Elfouly N, Fawzy A, Hassan A, Rashid M, Elsherbiny AS, Sieda B, Badwi NM, Mohammed MMH, Mohamed O, Habeeb MA, Worku M, Starr N, Desta S, Wondimu S, Abebe NS, Thomas E, Asele FA, Dabessa D, Abebe NS, Zerihun AB, Mentula P, Leppäniemi A, Sallinen V, Scalabre A, Frade F, Irtan S, Graffeille V, Gaignard E, Alimi Q, Alimi Q, Graffieille V, Gaignard E, Abbo O, Mouttalib S, Bouali O, Hervieux E, Aigrain Y, Botto N, Faure A, Fievet L, Panait N, Eyssartier E, Schmitt F, Podevin G, Parent V, Martin A, Arnaud AP, Muller C, Bonnard A, Peycelon M, Abantanga F, Boakye-Yiadom K, Bukari M, Owusu F, Awuku-Asabre J, Tabiri S, Bray LD, Lytras D, Psarianos K, Bamicha A, Kefalidi E, Gemenetzis G, Dervenis C, Gouvas N, Agalianos C, Kontos M, Kouraklis G, Karousos D, Germanos S, Marinos C, Anthoulakis C, Nikoloudis N, Mitroudis N, Recinos G, Estupinian S, Forno W, Azmitia JRA, Cabrera CCRR, Guevara R, Aguilera M, Mendez N, Mendizabal CAA, Ramazzini P, Urquizu MC, Tale F, Soley R, Barrios E, Barrios E, Rodríguez DEM, Velásquez CIP, Mérida SMC, Regalado F, Lopez M, Siguantay M, Lam FY, Szeto KJ, Szeto CCL, Li WS, Li KKK, Leung MF, Mak T, Ng S, Prasad SS, Kirishnan A, Gyanchandani N, Kumar BS, Rangarajan M, Bhat S, Sreedharan A, Kinnera SV, Reddy Y, Venugopal C, Kumar S, Mittal A, Nadkarni S, Lakshmi HN, Malik P, Limaye N, Pai S, Jain P, Khajanchi M, Satoskar S, Satoskar R, Mahamood AB, Sutanto EPR, Soeselo DA, Tedjaatmadja C, Rahmawati FN, Amandito R, Mayasari M, Al-Hasani RKMJ, Al-Hameedi HII, Ibraheem HI, Al-Azraqi IAA, Sabeeh L, Kamil R, Shawki M, Telfah MM, Rasendran A, Sheehan J, Kerley R, Normile C, Gilbert RW, Song J, Dablouk M, Mauro L, Dablouk MO, Hanrahan M, Kielty P, Marks E, Gosling S, Mccarthy M, Rasendran A, Mirghani D, Naqvi SA, Wong CS, Chung S, D'cruz R, Cahill R, Gosling SG, Mccarthy M, Rasendran A, Fahy C, Song J, Hanrahan M, Cadogan DD, Powell A, Gilbert R, Clifford C, Normile C, Driscoll A, Paul S, Lee C, Bowe R, Hutch W, Hanrahan M, Mohan H, O'neill M, Mealy K, Danelli P, Bondurri A, Maffioli A, Pasini M, Pata G, Roncali S, Silvani P, Carlucci M, Faccincani R, Bonavina L, Macchitella Y, Ceriani C, Tugnoli G, Di Saverio S, Khattab K, Paludi MA, Pata D, Cloro LM, Allegri A, Ansaloni L, Coccolini F, Veronese E, Bortolasi L, Hasheminia A, Nastri G, Canto MD, Cucumazzo S, Pata F, Benevento A, Tessera G, Grandinetti PP, Maniscalco A, Lamanna GL, Turati L, Sgroi G, Rausa E, Villa R, Monteleone M, Merlini D, Coccolini F, Ansaloni L, Allegri A, Grassi V, Cirocchi R, Cacurri A, Waleed H, Diab A, Elzowawi F, Jokubauskas M, Varkalys K, Venskutonis D, Pranevicius R, Ambrozeviciute V, Juciute S, Skardžiukaitė A, Venskutonis D, Bradulskis S, Urbanavicius L, Austraite A, Riauka R, Zilinskas J, Dambrauskas Z, Karumnas P, Urniezius Z, Zilinskiene R, Rudzenskaite A, Usaityte A, Montrimaite M, Kaselis N, Strazdas A, Jokubonis K, Maceviciute K, Beisa V, Poskus T, Strupas K, Laugzemys E, Kolosov A, Jotautas V, Rakita I, Mikalauskas S, Kazanavicius D, Rackauskas R, Strupas K, Poskus T, Beisa V, Rakauskas R, Preckailaite E, Coomber R, Johnson K, Nowers J, Periasammy D, Salleh A, Das A, Tze RGE, Kumar MN, Abdullah NAN, Kosai NR, Taher M, Rajan R, Chong HY, Roslani AC, Goh CC, Agius M, Borg E, Bezzina M, Bugeja R, Vella-Baldacchino M, Spina A, Psaila J, Francois-Coridon H, Tolg C, Colombani JF, Diaz-Zorrilla C, De La Medina AR, Gonzalez SC, Jacobe M, Mapasse D, Snyder E, Oumer R, Osman M, Mohammad A, Anyanwu LJ, Sheshe A, Adesina A, Faturoti O, Taiwo O, Ibrahim MH, Nasir AA, Suleiman SI, Adeniyi A, Adesanya O, Adebanjo A, Osuoji R, Atobatele K, Ogunyemi A, Williams O, Oludara M, Oshodi O, Ademuyiwa A, Lawal AO, Alakaloko F, Elebute O, Osinowo A, Bode C, Adesuyi A, Tade A, Adekoya A, Nwokoro C, Ayandipo OO, Lawal TA, Ajao AE, Ali SS, Odeyemi B, Olori S, Popoola A, Adeyeye A, Adeniran J, Lossius WJ, Havemann I, Thorsen K, Narvestad JK, Soreide K, Wold TB, Nymo L, Elsiddig M, Dar M, Bhopal KF, Iftikhar Z, Furqan MM, Nighat B, Jawaid M, Khalique A, Zil-E-Ali A, Rashid A, Dharamshi HA, Naqvi T, Faraz A, Anwar AW, Yaseen TM, Shamsi GS, Shamsi G, Yaseen T, Anwer W, Decoud HP, Aguilera O, Alvarez IIZ, Delgado JM, Vega GMM, Lohse HAS, Aguilar WLM, Chiong JAC, Bautista ACM, Huaman E, Zegarra S, Camacho R, Celis JMV, Pozo DAR, Hamasaki J, Temoche E, Herrera-Matta J, Torres CPG, Barreda LMA, Ojeda RRB, Garaycochea O, Mollo MC, Delgado MSFTL, Fujii F, Bautista ACM, Aguilar WLM, Chiong JAC, Durand SYA, Basto CAA, Rojas NMU, Yip SBS, Vergara ALC, Moran AER, Luque GB, Castro MR, Jaramillo RA, Sila GM, Lopez CE, De Leon MZP, Machaca M, Huaraya RC, Arenas A, López C, Puma CMH, Pino W, Hinojosa C, De Leon MZP, Limache S, Sila GM, Rodriguez LM, Melo R, Costa-Maia J, Muralha N, Sauvat F, Dan I, Hogea M, Eduard P, Bratu RM, Beuran M, Diaconescu IB, Martian BV, Iordache FM, Vartic M, Vida LC, Muntean LI, Mironescu AS, Nsengimana VJP, Niragire A, Ingabire JCA, Niyirera E, Zanini N, Jovine E, Landolfo G, Alomar IN, Alnuqaydan SA, Altwigry AM, Othman M, Osman N, Alqahtani E, Alzahrani M, Alyami R, Aljohani E, Alhabli I, Mikwar Z, Almuallem S, Aljohani E, Alyami R, Alzahrani M, Nawawi A, Bakhaidar M, Maghrabi AA, Alsaggaf M, Aljiffry M, Altaf A, Khoja A, Habeebullah A, Akeel N, Ghandora N, Almoflihi A, Huwait A, Al-Shammari A, Al-Mousa M, Alghamdi M, Adham W, Albeladi B, Alfarsi MA, Mahdi A, Al Awwad S, Altamimi A, Nouh T, Hassanain M, Aldhafeeri S, Sadig N, Algohary O, Aledrisy M, Gudal A, Alrifaie A, AlRowais M, Althwainy A, Shabkah A, Alamoudi U, Alrajraji M, Alghamdi B, Aljohani S, Daqeeq A, Al-Faifi JJ, Jennings V, Ngayu N, Moore R, Kong V, Kretzmann H, Connor K, Nel D, Sampson C, Spence R, Panieri E, Rayne S, Sishuba N, Tun M, Mphatsoe AM, Carreira JA, Teasdale E, Wagener M, Botes S, Du Plessis D, Fernandez-Bueno F, Aguilar-Jimenez J, Garcia-Marin JA, García LS, Florez LJG, Pacheco RDA, Pagnozzi J, Quezada JHJ, Rodicio JL, Minguez G, Rodríguez-Uría R, Ugalde P, Lopez-Arevalo C, Barneo L, Stuva JPG, Ortega-Vazquez I, Rodriguez L, Herrera N, Arachchi PP, Senanayake W, Senanayake MKJ, Arachchige LAJJ, Sivaganesh S, Samaraweera DI, Thanusan V, Musa AEK, Balila RMH, Mohamed MAEH, Ali H, Elabdin HZ, Hassan A, Mahdi S, Ahmed H, Idris SAI, Elsayed M, Elsayed M, Mahmoud M, Boijsen M, Lundgren PO, Gustafsson U, Kiasat A, Wogensen F, Wogensen F, Jurdell E, Thorell A, Thorarinsdottir H, Utter M, Sundstrom SM, Wredberg C, Kjellin A, Nyberg J, Frisk B, Sund M, Andersson L, Gunnarsson U, Cengiz Y, Ahlqvist S, Björklund I, Royson H, Weber P, Pahlsson HI, Borin E, Hjertberg M, Royson H, Weber P, Schmid R, Schivo D, Despotidis V, Breitenstein S, Staerkle RF, Schadde E, Deichsel F, Gerosa A, Nocito A, Raptis DA, Mijuskovic B, Zuber M, Eisner L, Kruspi S, Reinisch KB, Schoewe C, Novak A, Palma AF, Teufelberger G, Kimaro M, King R, Balkan AZA, Gumar M, Yavuz MA, Karabacak U, Lap G, Ozkan BB, Ozkan BB, Karakahya M, Adams R, Morton R, Henderson L, Gratton R, Clement KD, Chang KY, Mcnish D, Mcintosh R, Milligan W, Skelly B, Anderson-Knight H, Lawther R, Onimowo J, Shatkar V, Tharmalingam S, Woin E, Fautz T, Ziff O, Dindyal S, Arman S, Talukder S, Arman S, Gadhvi V, Talukder S, Chew LS, Heath J, Blencowe N, Hallam S, Gash K, Mannu GS, Zachariades DC, Snaith AC, Hettiarachchi TS, Nesaratnam A, Wheeler J, McCullagh D, Clements JM, Khan A, Koumpa F, Neophytou C, Roth J, Soon WC, Deputy M, Ahmed A, Ashton A, Vincent J, Almy J, Khan T, Allen JLY, Mcintyre CJ, Marshall DC, Sykes M, Behar N, Jordan H, Rajjoub Y, Sherman T, White T, Watts A, Ardley R, Arulampalam T, Shah A, Brown D, Blower E, Sutton P, Gasteratos K, Vimalachandran D, Magee C, Irwin G, Mcguigan A, Mcaleer S, Morgan C, Braungart S, Lafferty K, Labib P, Tanase A, Mangan C, Reza L, Reza L, Tanase A, Mangan C, Woodward H, Gouldthorpe C, Turner M, Wild JRL, Malik TA, Proctor VK, Hewage K, Davies J, Dubois A, Sarwary S, Zardab A, Grant A, Mcintyre R, Mogan YP, Ho W, Chong BFHK, Tewari S, Humm G, Farinella E, Hall NJ, Wright NJ, Major CP, Xerri T, De Bono P, Amin J, Farhad M, Camilleri-Brennan JF, Robertson AGN, Xerri T, Swann J, Richards J, Amin J, Jabbar A, De Bono P, Attard M, Burns H, Macdonald E, Baldacchino M, Skehan J, Camilleri-Brennan J, Hall TF, Gimzewska M, Mclachlan G, Shah J, Giles J, Chiu S, Weber B, Chiu SMY, Highcock S, Hassan M, Beasley W, Vlachogiorgos A, Dias S, Maharaj G, Mcdonald R, Macdonald A, Witherspoon P, Baird A, Sarmah P, Green N, Youssef H, Cross K, Rees CM, Van Duren B, Upchurch E, Khan K, Abudeeb H, Hammad A, Karandikar S, Bowley D, Karim A, Chachulski W, Richardson L, Dawnay G, Thompson B, Mistry A, Bhangu A, Ghetia M, Roy S, Al-Obaedi O, Ghetia M, Das K, Prabhudesai A, Cocker DM, Tan JJ, Tyler R, Di Franco F, Ayyar S, Vivekanantham S, Gokani S, Gillespie M, Gudlaugsdottir K, Pezas T, Currow C, Kim MY, Birring A, Edwards J, Ali A, Das S, Jha M, Atkinson K, Luck J, Fozard T, Puttick M, Salama Y, Shah R, Ibrahem AA, Ebdewi H, Gravante G, El-Rabaa S, Nnajiuba H, Allott R, Bhargava A, Chan Z, Hassan Z, Makinde M, Hemingway D, Dean R, Boddy A, Aber A, Patel V, Parakh J, Parthiban S, Ubhi HK, Hosein SP, Ward S, Malik K, Jennings L, Newton T, Alkhouri M, Kang MK, Houlden C, Barry J, Raza I, Farquharson A, Bhattacharya S, Milligan W, Chang K, Henderson L, Wilson MSJ, Neo YN, Ibrahim I, Chan E, Peck FS, Lim PJ, North AS, Blundell R, Williamson A, Fouad D, Minocha A, Mccarthy K, Court E, Chambers A, Yee J, Tham JC, Beaton C, Walsh U, Lockey J, Bokhari S, Howells L, Griffiths M, Yallop L, Singh S, Nasher O, Jackson P, Puttick M, Luck J, Fozard T, Shariffuddin AM, Ho WC, Wilson MS, Pabla G, Ramzi S, Zeidan S, Doughty J, Sinha S, Davenport R, Lewis J, Duffy L, Mcaleer E, Williams E, Som R, Javed O, Boal M, Harrison N, Tafazal H, Javed O, Brogden T, Nepogodiev D, Griffiths E, Obute RD, Glover TE, Clark DJ, Boshnaq M, Akhtar M, Capleton P, Doughan S, Rabie M, Mohamed I, Samuel D, Dickson L, Kennedy M, Dempster E, Brown E, Maple N, Monaghan E, Wolf B, Garland A, Mcphee A, Anderson D, Anderson R, Hassan S, Sutton P, Smith D, Lund J, Boereboom C, Murphy J, Tierney G, Tou S, Zimmermann EF, Smart NJ, Warwick AM, Stasinou T, Daniels I, Findlay-Cooper K, Mitrasinovic S, Ray S, Varcada M, D'Souza R, Omara S, Spurr M, Parkinson L, Hanks A, Ma J, Abington E, Ramcharn M, Williams G, Winstanley J, Kennedy ED, Yeung EN, Fergusson SJ, Jones C, O'neill S, Lim SJ, Liew I, Nair H, Fairfield C, Oh J, Koh S, Wilson A, Fairfield C, Anandkumar D, Kirupagaran A, Jones TF, Torrance HD, Fowler AJ, Chandrakumar C, Patel P, Ashraf SF, Lakhani SM, Mclean AL, Basson S, Batt J, Bowman C, Stoddart M, Benons N, Mason C, Harrison R, Quayle J, Barker T, Summerour V, Harper E, Smith C, Hampton M, Pitt SK, Ward AE, O'Connor T, Heywood EG, Drake TM, Chowdhury A, Hossaini S, Watson NF, Mckechnie D, Farah A, Chun A, Koh H, Lim G, Sunderland G, Gould L, Chambers A, Munipalle PC, Rooney H, Browning DRL, Pereira B, Nemeth K, Decker E, Giuliani S, Shalaby A, Shaikh S, Tan CY, Palkhi EYA, Szczap A, Chidambaram S, Chen CY, Kulasabanathan K, Chhabra S, Kostov E, Harbord P, Barnacle J, Palliyil MM, Zikry M, Porter J, Raslan C, Saeed M, Hafiz S, Soltani N, Baillie K, Singh P, Sheth S, Patel K, Khalili M, Choi J, Benger M, Marples L, Macfarlane A, Thurairaja R, Boyce T, Whewell H, Jones E, Th'ng F, Robertson N, Mirza A, Saeed H, Galloway S, Elena G, Afzal M, Zakir M, Sodde P, Hand C, Sriram A, Clark T, Holton P, Livesey A, Sinha Y, Iqbal FM, Bharj IS, Rotundo A, Jenvey C, Slade R, Golding D, Haines S, Ne'ma Abdullah AA, Tilston TW, Loughran D, Donoghue D, Giacci L, Sherif MA, Harrison P, Tang A, Kotecha D, Elshaer M, Urbonas T, Riaz A, Chapman A, Acharya P, Shalhoub J, Grossart C, McMorran D, Mlotshwa M, Hawkins W, Loizides S, Krishna K, Orchard M, Ho CW, Thomson P, Khan S, Taylor F, Shukla J, Howie EE, Macdonald L, Komolafe O, Mcintyre N, Cragg J, Parker J, Stewart D, Lintin L, Tracy J, Farooq T, Molina G, Kaafarani H, Luque L, Beyene R, Sava J, Scott M, Swaroop M, Kennedy R, Azodo IA, Heffernan D, Chun T, Stephen A, Sion M, Weinstein MS, Punja V, Bugaev N, Goodstein M, Razmdjou S, Etchill E, Puyana JC, Kesinger M, Napolitano L, To K, Hemmila M, Todd O, Jenner E, Hoogakker E, Grizhja B, Ymeri S, Galiqi G, Klappenbach R, Antezana D, Beleño AEM, Costa C, Sanchez B, Aviles S, Modolo MM, Fermani CG, Balmaceda R, Villalobos S, Carmona JM, Hamill D, Deutschmann P, Sandler S, Cox D, Nataraja R, Sharpin C, Ljuhar D, Gray D, Haines M, Iyer D, Niranjan N, D'Amours S, Ashtari M, Franco H, Mitul AR, Karim S, Aman NF, Estee MM, Salma U, Razzaque J, Kanta TH, Tori SA, Alamin S, Roy S, Al Amin S, Karim R, Haque M, Faruq A, Iftekhar F, O'Shea M, Padmore G, Jonnalagadda R, Litvin A, Filatau A, Paulouski D, Shubianok M, Shachykava T, Khokha D, Khokha V, Djivoh F, Ismaïl L, Dossou F, Seto DM, Gbessi DG, Noukpozounkou B, Souaibou YI, Keke KR, Hodonou F, Ahounou EYS, Alihonou T, Dénakpo M, Ahlonsou G, Bedada AG, Nsengiyumva C, Kwizera S, Barendegere V, Choi P, Stock S, Jamal L, Firdouse M, Zani A, Azzie G, Kushwaha S, Agarwal A, Chen TL, Yip C, Montes I, Zapata F, Sierra S, Lanau MIV, Arango MCM, Restrepo IM, Sierra S, Giraldo RSR, Arango MCM, Domini E, Karlo R, Mihanovic J, Youssef M, Elfeki H, Thabet W, Sanad A, Tawfik G, Zaki A, Abdel-Hameed N, Mostafa M, Omar MFW, Ghanem A, Abdallah E, Denewar A, Emara E, Rashad E, Sakr A, Elashry R, Emile S, Khafagy T, Elhamouly S, Elfarargy A, Mohamed AM, Nagy GS, Esam A, Elwy E, Hammad A, Khallaf S, Ibrahim E, Saidbadr A, Moustafa A, Mohammed AE, Elgheriany M, Abdelmageed E, Al Raouf EA, Elbanby ES, Elmasry M, Farahat MM, Mansor EY, Hegazy EM, Gamal E, Gamal H, Kandil H, Abdelrouf DM, Moaty M, Gamal D, El-Sagheer N, Salah M, Magdy S, Salah A, Essam A, Ali A, Badawy M, Ahmed S, Mohamed M, Assal A, Sleem M, Ebidy M, Elrazek AA, Zahran D, Adam N, Nazir M, Hassanein AB, Ismail A, Elsawy A, Mamdouh R, Mabrouk M, Ahmed LAM, Alnaby MH, Magdy E, Abd-Elmawla M, Fahim M, Mowafy B, Mahmoud MI, Allam M, Alkelani M, El Gendy NH, Aboul-Naga MS, El-Din RA, Elgendy AH, Ismail M, Shalaby M, Elsharkawy AA, Moghazy ME, Elbisomy KH, Shakshouk HAG, Hamed MF, Ebidy MM, Abdelkader M, Karkeet M, Ahmed H, Adel I, Omar ME, Ibrahim M, Ghoneim O, Hesham O, Gamal S, Hilal K, Arafa O, Awad SA, Salem M, Elsherif FA, Elsabbagh N, Aboelsoud MR, Rida AHEF, Hossameldin A, Hany E, Asar YH, Anwar N, Gadelkarim M, Abdelhady S, Morshedy EM, Saad R, Soliman N, Salama M, Ezzat E, Mohamed A, Ibrahim A, Fergany A, Mohammed S, Reda A, Allam Y, Saad HA, Abdelfatah A, Fathy AM, El-Sehily A, Kasem EA, Hassan ATA, Mohammed AR, Saad AG, Elfouly Y, Elfouly N, Ibrahim A, Hassaan A, Mohammed MM, Elhoseny G, Magdy M, Elkhalek EA, Zakaria Y, Ezzat T, El Dahab AA, Kelany M, Arafa S, Hassan OMM, Badwi NM, Sleem AS, Ahmed H, Abdelbadeai K, Abdullah MA, Lokman MAA, Bahar S, Abdelazeam AR, Adelshone A, Hasnan MB, Zulkifli A, Kamarulzamil SNA, Elhendawy A, Latif A, Adnan AB, Shaharuddin S, Majid AHHA, Amreia M, Al-Marakby D, Salma M, Ismail MJB, Basir ERM, Ali CDM, Ata AY, Nasr M, Rezq A, Sheta A, Tariq S, Sallam AE, Darwish AK, Elmihy S, Elhadry S, Farag A, Hajeh H, Abdelaal A, Aglan A, Zohair A, Essam M, Moussa O, El-Gizawy E, Samy M, Ali S, Elhalawany E, Ata A, El Halawany M, Nashat M, Soliman S, Elazab A, Samy M, Abdelaziz MA, Ibrahim K, Ibrahim AM, Gado A, Hantour U, Eldeen EA, Loaloa MR, Abouzaid A, Eldin MAB, Hashad E, Sroor F, Gamil D, Abdulhakeem EM, Zakaria M, Mohamed F, Abubakr M, Ali E, Magdy H, Ramadan MT, Mohamed MA, Mansour S, Amin HAA, Mohamed AR, Saami M, Elsayed NAR, Tarek A, Mahmoud SME, El Sayed IM, Reda A, Shawky MY, Salem MM, El-Din SA, Soliman NA, Talaat M, Alaael-Dein S, Elhusseiny AAE, Abdullah N, Elshaar M, Ibraheem AA, Abdulaziz H, Ismail MK, Madkor MH, Abdelaty M, Abdel-Kader SM, Salah OM, Eldafrawy M, Eldeeb AZ, Eid MM, Attia A, El-Dien KS, Shwky A, Badenjki MA, Soliman A, Al Attar SM, Sayed F, Sabour FA, Azizeldine MG, Shawqi M, Hashim A, Aamer A, Abdelraouf AM, Abdelshakour M, Ibrahim A, Mahmoud B, Mahmoud MA, Qenawy M, Rashed AM, Dahy A, Sayed M, Shamsedine AW, Mohamed B, Hasan A, Saad MM, Bassit KA, El-Latif NKA, Elzahed N, El Kashash A, Bekhet NM, Hafez S, Gad A, Maher ME, Elsameea AA, Hafez M, Sabe A, Ahmed A, Shahine A, Dawood K, Gaafar S, Husseiny R, Aboelmagd O, Soliman A, Mesbah N, Emadeldin H, Al Meligy A, Bekhet AH, Hasan D, Alhady K, Sabe AK, Elnajjar MA, Aboelella M, Hamsho W, Hassan I, Saad H, Abdelazim G, Mahmoud H, Wael N, Kandil AM, Magdy A, Elkholy SS, Adel BE, Dabbour K, Elsherbiney S, Mattar O, Abdrabou AK, Aly MYM, Geuoshy A, Elnagar A, Ahmed S, Abdelmotaleb I, Saleh AA, Saeed M, Mahmoud S, Tawfik BA, Ismail SA, Zakaria E, Gad MO, Elhelbawy MS, Bassem M, Maraie N, Elhadary NM, Semeda N, Mohamed SR, Bakry HM, Essam AA, Tarek D, Ashour K, Elhadad A, Abdel-Aty A, Rakha I, Matter SM, Abdelhamed R, Abdelkader O, Hassaan A, Soliman Y, Mohamed A, Ghanem S, Farouk SAM, Ibrahim EM, El-Taher E, Mostafa M, Badr MFM, Elsemelawy R, El-Sawy A, Bakr A, Al Rafati AAR, Saar S, Reinsoo A, Talving P, Seyoum N, Worku T, Fitsum A, Tolonen M, Leppäniemi A, Sallinen V, Parmentier B, Peycelon M, Irtan S, Dardenne S, Robert E, Maillot B, Courboin E, Arnaud AP, Hascoet J, Abbo O, Kaci AA, Prudhomme T, Ballouhey Q, Grosos C, Fourcade L, Cecilia T, Jean-Francois C, Helene FC, Delforge X, Haraux E, Dousset B, Schiavone R, Gaujoux S, Marret JB, Haffreingue A, Rod J, Renaux-Petel M, Lecompte JF, Bréaud J, Gastaldi P, Taieb C, Claire R, Anis E, Bustangi N, Lopez M, Scalabre A, Grella MG, Mariani A, Podevin G, Schmitt F, Hervieux E, Broch A, Muller C, Tabiri S, Kojo ATT, Bandoh D, Abantanga F, Kyereh M, Asumah H, Appiah EK, Wondoh P, Gyedu A, Dally C, Agbedinu K, Amoah M, Yifieyeh A, Owusu F, Amoako-Boateng M, Dayie M, Hagan R, Debrah S, Ohene-Yeboah M, Clegg-Lampety JN, Etwire V, Dakubo J, Essoun S, Bonney W, Glover-Addy H, Osei-Nketiah S, Amoako J, Adu-Aryee N, Appeadu-Mensah W, Bediako-Bowan A, Dedey F, Ekow M, Akatibo E, Yakubu M, Kordorwu HEK, Asare-Bediako K, Tackie E, Aaniana K, Acquah E, Opoku-Agyeman R, Avoka A, Kusi K, Maison K, Gyamfi FE, Barnabas GN, Abdul-Latif S, Amoako PT, Davor A, Dassah V, Dagoe E, Kwakyeafriyie P, Akoto E, Ackom E, Mensah E, Atkins ET, Coompson CL, Ivros N, Ferousis C, Kalles V, Agalianos C, Kyriazanos I, Barkolias C, Tselos A, Tzikos G, Voulgaris E, Lytras D, Bamicha A, Psarianos K, Stefanopoulos A, Patoulias I, Sfougaris D, Valioulis I, Balalis D, Korkolis D, Manatakis DK, Kyrou G, Karabelias G, Papaskarlatos IA, Konstantina K, Zampitis N, Germanos S, Papailia A, Theodosopoulos T, Gkiokas G, Mitroudi M, Panteli C, Feidantsis T, Farmakis K, Kyziridis D, Ioannidis O, Parpoudi S, Gemenetzis G, Parasyris S, Anthoulakis C, Nikoloudis N, Margaritis M, Aguilera-Arevalo ML, Coyoy-Gaitan O, Rosales J, Tale L, Soley R, Barrios E, Rodriguez STT, Galvez CP, Cruz DH, Rosenberg GS, Matheu A, Cohen DM, Paul M, Charles A, Lam JCY, Yeung MHA, Fok CYJ, Li KHG, Lai AC, Cheung YHE, Wong HY, Leung KW, Lee TSB, Lam WH, Dao W, Kwok SH, Chan TK, Ng YK, Mak T, Liu Q, Foo CC, Yang J, Kumar B, Bhatnagar A, Upadhyaya V, Kumar S, Muddebihal U, Dar W, Janardha KC, Alexander P, Aruldas N, Adella FJ, Rulie AS, Iskandar F, Setiawan J, Evajelista CV, Natalie H, Suyadi A, Gunawan R, Karismaningtyas H, Mata LPS, Andika FFA, Hasanah A, Widiastini TA, Purwaningsih NA, Mukin ADF, Rahmah DF, Nurqistan HD, Arsyad HM, Adhitama N, Jeo WS, Sutandi N, Clarissa A, Gultom PA, Billy M, Haloho A, Amandito R, Johanna N, Lee F, Dorani RMNR, Glynn M, Alherz M, Goh W, Shiwani HA, Sproule L, Conlon KC, Bala M, Kedar A, Turati L, Bianco F, Steccanella F, Gallo G, Trompetto M, Clerico G, Papandrea M, Sammarco G, Sacco R, Benevento A, Pata F, Giavarini L, Giglio MC, Bucci L, Pagano G, Sollazzo V, Peltrini R, Luglio G, Birindelli A, Di Saverio S, Tugnoli G, Paludi MA, Mingrone P, Pata D, Selvaggi F, Selvaggi L, Pellino G, Di Martino N, Curletti G, Aonzo P, Galleano R, Berti S, Francone E, Boni S, Lorenzon L, Lo Conte A, Balducci G, Confalonieri G, Pesenti G, Gavagna L, Vasquez G, Targa S, Occhionorelli S, Andreotti D, Pata G, Armellini A, Chiesa D, Aquilino F, Chetta N, Picciariello A, Abdelkhalek M, Belli A, De Franciscis S, Bigaran A, Favero A, Basso SM, Salusso P, Perino M, Mochet S, Sasia D, Riente F, Migliore M, Merlini D, Basilicò S, Corbellini C, Lazzari V, Macchitella Y, Bonavina L, Angelieri D, Coletta D, Falaschi F, Catani M, Reali C, Malavenda M, Del Basso C, Ribaldi S, Coletti M, Natili A, Depalma N, Iannone I, Antoniozzi A, Rossi D, Gui D, Perrotta G, Ripa M, Giardino FR, Foco M, Vicario E, Coccolini F, Ansaloni L, Nita GE, Leone N, Bondurri A, Maffioli A, Simioni A, De Boni D, Pasquali S, Goldin E, Vendramin E, Ciccioli E, Tedeschi U, Bortolasi L, Violi P, Campagnaro T, Conci S, Lazzari G, Iacono C, Gulielmi A, Manfreda S, Rinaldi A, Ringressi MN, Brunoni B, Salamone G, Mangiapane M, De Marco P, La Brocca A, Tutino R, Silvestri V, Licari L, Fontana T, Falco N, Cocorullo G, Shalaby M, Sileri P, Arcudi C, Bsisu I, Aljboor K, Abusalem L, Alnusairat A, Qaissieh A, Al-Dakka E, Ababneh A, Halhouli O, Yusufali T, Mohammed H, Lando J, Parker R, Ndegwa W, Jokubauskas M, Gribauskaite J, Venskutonis D, Kuliavas J, Dulskas A, Samalavicius NE, Jasaitis K, Parseliunas A, Nevieraite V, Montrimaite M, Slapelyte E, Dainius E, Riauka R, Dambrauskas Z, Subocius A, Venclauskas L, Gulbinas A, Bradulskis S, Kasputyte S, Mikuckyte D, Kiudelis M, Zilinskas J, Jankus T, Petrikenas S, Pažuskis M, Urniežius Z, Vilčinskas M, Banaitis VJ, Gaižauskas V, Grisin E, Mazrimas P, Rackauskas R, Drungilas M, Lagunavicius K, Lipnickas V, Majauskyté D, Jotautas V, Abaliksta T, Uščinas L, Simutis G, Ladukas A, Danys D, Laugzemys E, Mikalauskas S, Poskus T, Sruogiene EZ, Višinskas P, Žilinskienė R, Dragatas D, Burmistrovas A, Tverskis Z, Vaicius A, Mazelyte R, Zadoroznas A, Kaselis N, Žiubrytė G, Rahantasoa FCFP, Samison LH, Rasoaherinomenjanahary F, Tolotra TEC, Mukuzunga C, Msosa V, Kwatiwani C, Msiska N, Chai FY, Asilah SMD, Syibrah KZ, Chin PX, Salleh A, Riswan NZ, Roslani AC, Chong HY, Aziz NA, Poh KS, Chai CA, Kumar S, Taher MM, Kosai NR, Aziz DNA, Rajan R, Julaihi R, Jethwani DL, Yahaya MT, Abdullah NAN, Mathew SW, Chung KJ, Nirumal MK, Tze RGE, Ali SAWEW, Gan YY, Ting JRS, Sii SSY, Koay KL, Tan YK, Cheah AEZ, Wong CY, Nur'Azmah Tuan Mat T, Chow CYN, Har PA, Der Y, Tew YY, Henry F, Low X, Neo YT, Heng HE, Kong SN, Gan C, Mok YT, Tan YW, Palayan K, Tata MD, Cheong YJ, Gunaseelan K, 'Ain Wan Mohd Nasir WN, Yoganathan P, Lee EX, Saw JE, Yeang LJ, Koh PY, Lim SY, Teo SY, Grech N, Magri D, Cassar K, Mizzi C, Falzon M, Shaikh N, Scicluna R, Zammit S, Borg E, Mizzi S, Brincat SD, Tembo T, Le VTH, Grima T, Sammut K, Carabott K, Farrugia A, Zarb C, Navarro A, Dimech T, Camilleri GM, Bertuello I, Dalli J, Bonavia K, Corro-Diaz S, Manriquez-Reyes M, la Medina AR, Abdelhamid A, Hrora A, Benammi S, Bachri H, Abbouch M, Boukhal K, Bennai RM, Belkouchi A, Jabal MS, Benyaiche C, Vermaas M, Duinhouwer L, Pastora J, Wood G, Merlo MS, Ajao A, Ayandipo O, Lawal T, Abdurrazzaaq A, Alada M, Nasir A, Adeniran J, Habeeb O, Popoola A, Adeyeye A, Adebanjo A, Adesanya O, Adeniyi A, Mendel H, Bello B, Muktar U, Osinowo A, Olajide TO, Oshati O, Ihediwa G, Adenekan B, Nwinee V, Alakaloko F, Ademuyiwa A, Elebute O, Lawal A, Bode C, Olugbemi M, Adesina A, Faturoti O, Odutola O, Adebola O, Onuoha C, Taiwo O, Williams O, Balogun F, Ajai O, Oludara M, Njokanma I, Osuoji R, Kache S, Ajah J, Makama J, Adamu A, Baba S, Aliyu M, Aliyu S, Ukwenya Y, Aliyu H, Sholadoye T, Daniyan M, Ogunsua O, Anyanwu LJ, Sheshe A, Mohammad A, Olori S, Mshelbwala P, Odeyemi B, Samson G, Timothy OK, Samuel SA, Ajiboye A, Adeyeye A, Amole I, Abiola O, Olaolorun A, Søreide K, Veen T, Kanani A, Styles K, Herikstad R, Larsen JW, Søreide JA, Jensen E, Gran M, Aahlin EK, Gaarder T, Monrad-Hansen PW, Næss PA, Lauzikas G, Wiborg J, Holte S, Augestad KM, Banipal GS, Monteleone M, Moe TT, Schultz JK, Al-Taher T, Hamdan A, Salman A, Saadeh R, Musleh A, Jaradat D, Abushamleh S, Hanoun S, Qumbos AA, Hamarshi A, Taher AA, Qawasmi I, Qurie K, Altarayra M, Ghannam M, Shaheen A, Herebat A, Abdelhaq A, Shalabi A, Abu-Toyour M, Asi F, Shamasneh A, Atiyeh A, Mustafa M, Zaa'treh R, Dabboor M, Alaloul E, Baraka H, Meqbil J, Al-Buhaisi A, Elshami M, Afana S, Jaber S, Alyacoubi S, Abuowda Y, Idress T, Abuqwaider E, Al-Saqqa S, Bowabsak A, El Jamassi A, Hasanain D, Al-Farram H, Salah M, Firwana A, Hamdan M, Awad I, Ashour A, Al Barrawi FE, Al-Khatib A, Al-Faqawi M, Fares M, Elmashala A, Adawi M, Adawi I, Khreishi R, Khreishi R, Ashour A, Ghaben A, Nadeem N, Saqlain M, Abbasy J, Alvi AR, Gala T, Shahzad N, Bhopal KF, Iftikhar Z, Butt MT, Asaat Ul Razi S, Ahmed A, Niazi AK, Raza I, Baluch F, Raza A, Bani-Sadar A, Qureshi AU, Adil M, Raza A, Javaid M, Waqar M, Khan MA, Arshad MM, Amjad M, Vega GMM, Cardozo JT, Roche MO, Servin GRP, Lohse HAS, Lopez LIP, Cardozo RAM, Espinoza F, Rojas ADP, Sanchez D, Samaniego CS, Torres SG, Calua AC, Razuri C, Ortiz N, Rodriguez X, Carrasco N, Saravia F, Miyasato HS, Valcarcel-Saldaña M, Bermúdez YEA, Carpio J, Panez WR, Orbegozo PAT, Dueñas CG, Espinoza KT, Barrantes AMS, Bravo JAC, Shu S, Fuentes-Rivera L, Fernández C, Romani D, Málaga B, Ye J, Velasquez R, Salcedo J, Contreras-Vergara AL, Mejia AGV, Montejo MSG, Salas MDCE, Ticona WA, Vargas M, Sila GCM, Mas R, Del Pilar Paucar A, Velásquez AJR, Robledo-Rabanal A, Solis LAZ, Espinoza KT, Hamaguchi JLH, Farfan ESF, Barrientos LAM, Matta JJH, Mora JJV, Redota MAP, Roxas MF, Maño MJB, Parreno-Sacdalan MD, Lapitan MC, Almanon CL, Walędziak M, Roszkowski R, Janik M, Lasek A, Major P, Radkowiak D, Rubinkiewicz M, Fernandes C, Costa-Maia J, Melo R, Muntean L, Mironescu AS, Vida LC, Kourdouli A, Popa M, Mircea H, Vartic M, Diaconescu B, Bratu MR, Negoi I, Beuran M, Ciubotaru C, Ingabire JCA, Mutabazi AZ, Uzabumwana N, Duhoranenayo D, Jovine E, Zanini N, Landolfo G, Aljiffry M, Idris F, Alghamdi MSA, Maghrabi A, Altaf A, Alkaaki A, Khoja A, Nawawi A, Turkustani S, Khalifah E, Gudal A, Albiety A, Sahel S, Alshareef R, Alzahrani MNA, Alghamdi A, Alhazmi W, Al Saied G, Alamoudi M, Riaz MM, Hassanain M, Alhassan B, Altamimi A, Alyahya R, Al Subaie N, Al Bastawis F, Altamimi A, Nouh T, Khan R, Radojkovic M, Jeremic L, Nestorovic M, Law JH, Tan KSK, Tan RCK, Tan JK, Joel LWL, Lieske B, Chan XW, Leong FQH, Chong CS, Koh S, Lee KY, Lee KC, Pluke K, Dedekind B, Nashidengo P, Hampton MI, Joosten J, Sobnach S, Roodt L, Sander A, Pape J, Spence R, Maistry N, Ndwambi P, Kinandu K, Tun M, Du Toit F, Ellison Q, Burger S, Grobler DC, Khulu LB, Moore R, Jennings V, Leusink A, Kariem N, Gouws J, Chu K, Bougard H, Noor F, Dell A, Rayne S, Van Straten S, Khamajeet A, Tshisola SK, Kabongo K, Kong V, Moodley Y, Anderson F, Madiba T, du Plooy F, Hartford L, Chilton G, Karjiker P, Mabitsela ME, Ndlovu SR, Badicel M, Jaich R, Ruiz-Tovar J, Garcia-Florez L, Otero-Díez JL, Pérez VR, Suárez NA, García JM, Moreno SC, Collado MV, Carneros VJ, Septiem JG, Gonzalez M, Picardo A, Esteban E, Ferrero E, Ortega I, Espin-Basany E, Blanco-Colino R, Andriola V, García LS, Contreras E, Bernardo CG, Pagnozzi J, Sanz S, de León AM, Dorismé A, Rodicio J, Suarez A, Stuva J, Vico TD, Fernandez-Vega L, Soldevila-Verdeguer C, Sena-Ruiz F, Pujol-Cano N, Diaz-Jover P, Garcia-Perez JM, Segura-Sampedro JJ, Pineño-Flores C, Ambrona-Zafra D, Craus-Miguel A, Jimenez-Morillas P, Mazzella A, Jayathilake AB, Thalgaspitiya SPB, Wijayarathna LS, Wimalge PMSN, Sanni HA, Ndajiwo A, Okenabirhie O, Homeida A, Younis A, Omer OA, Abdulaziz M, Mussad A, Adam A, Cengiz Y, Björklund I, Ahlqvist S, Ahlqvist S, Thorell A, Wogensen F, Sokratous A, Breistrand M, Thorarinsdottir H, Sigurdadottir J, Nikberg M, Chabok A, Hjertberg M, Elbe P, Saraste D, Rutkowski W, Forlin L, Niska K, Sund M, Oswald D, Peros G, Bluelle R, Reinisch K, Frey D, Palma A, Raptis DA, Zumbühl L, Zuber M, Schmid R, Werder G, Nocito A, Gerosa A, Mahanty S, Widmer LW, Müller J, Gübeli A, Zuk G, Gulcicek OB, Altinel Y, Vartanoglu T, Kose E, Karahan SR, Aydin MC, Sahbaz NA, Halicioglu I, Alis H, Sapci I, Adıyaman C, Pektaş AM, Cengiz TB, Tansoker I, Işler V, Cevik M, Mutlu D, Ozben V, Ozmen BB, Bayram S, Yolcu S, Kobal BB, Toto ÖF, Çakaloğlu HC, Karabulut K, Mutlu V, Ozkan BB, Celik S, Semiz A, Bodur S, Gül E, Murutoglu B, Yildirim R, Baki BE, Arslan E, Ulusahin M, Guner A, Walker N, Shrimanker N, Stoddart M, Cole S, Breslin R, Srinivasan R, Elshaer M, Hunter K, Al-Bahrani A, Liew I, Mairs NG, Rocke A, Dick L, Qureshi M, Chowdhury D, Wright N, Skerritt C, Kufeji D, Ho A, Dissanayake T, Tennakoon A, Ali W, Lim SJ, Tan C, O'Neill S, Jones C, Knight S, Nassif D, Sharma A, Warren O, White R, Mehdi A, Post N, Kalakouti E, Dashnyam E, Stourton F, Mykoniatis I, Currow C, Wong F, Gupta A, Shatkar V, Luck J, Kadiwar S, Smedley A, Wakefield R, Herrod P, Blackwell J, Lund J, Cohen F, Bandi A, Giuliani S, Bond-Smith G, Pezas T, Farhangmehr N, Urbonas T, Perenyei M, Ireland P, Blencowe N, Bowling K, Bunting D, Longstaff L, Smart N, Keogh K, Jeon H, Iqbal MR, Khosla S, Jeffery A, Perera J, Teasdale E, Ibrahem AA, Alhammali T, Salama Y, Kabariti R, Oram S, Kidd T, Cullen F, Owen C, Wilson M, Chiu S, Sarafilovic H, Ploski J, Evans E, Abbas A, Kamya S, Ishak N, Bisset C, Andress C, Chin YR, Patel P, Evans D, Jeffery A, Perera J, Haslegrave A, Boggon A, Laurie K, Connor K, Mann T, Nepogodiev D, Mansuri A, Davies R, Griffiths E, Shahbaz AR, Eng C, Din F, L'Heveder A, Park EH, Ravishankar R, McIntosh K, Yau JD, Chan L, McGarvie S, Tang L, Lim H, Yap S, Park J, Ng ZH, Mirza S, Ang YL, Walls L, Teasdale E, Roy C, Paterson-Brown S, Camilleri-Brennan J, Mclean K, D'Souza MS, Pronin S, Henshall DE, Ter EZ, Fouad D, Minocha A, English W, Morgan C, Townsend D, Maciejec L, Mahdi S, Akpenyi O, Hall E, Caydiid H, Rob Z, Abbott T, Torrance HD, Irwin G, Johnston R, Gani MA, Gravante G, Rajmohan S, Majid K, Dindyal S, Smith C, Palliyil M, Patel S, Nicholson L, Harvey N, Baillie K, Shillito S, Kershaw S, Bamford R, Orton P, Reunis E, Tyler R, Soon WC, Jama GM, Dhillon D, Patel K, Nanthakumaran S, Heard R, Chen KY, Barmayehvar B, Datta U, Kamarajah SK, Karandikar S, Tani SI, Monaghan E, Donnelly P, Walker M, Parakh J, Blacker S, Kaul A, Paramasivan A, Farag S, Nessa A, Awadallah S, Lim J, Ng JCK, Gash K, Kiran RP, Murray A, Etchill E, Dasari M, Puyana J, Haddad N, Zielinski M, Choudhry A, Caliman C, Beamon M, Duane T, Narayanan R, Swaroop M, Myers J, Deal R, Schadde E, Hemmila M, Napolitano L, To K, Makupe A, Musowoya J, Maimbo M, Van Der Naald N, Kumwenda D, Reece-Smith A, Otten K, Verbeek A, Prins M, Suarez AAB, Balmaceda R, Deane C, Dijan E, Elfiky M, Koskenvuo L, Thollot A, Limoges B, Capito C, Alexandre C, Kotobi H, Leroux J, Rod J, Pinnagoda K, Henric N, Azzis O, Rosello O, Francois P, Etienne S, Buisson P, Hmila S, Clegg-Lamptey JN, Imoro O, Abem OE, Wondoh P, Papageorgiou D, Soulou V, Asturias S, Peña L, Kumar B, O'Connor DB, Luc AR, Russo AA, Ruzzenente A, Taddei A, Cona C, Bottini C, Pascale G, Rotunno G, Solaini L, Pascale MM, Notarnicola M, Corbellino M, Sacco M, Ubiali P, Cautiero R, Bocchetti T, Muzio E, Guglielmo V, Morandi E, Mao P, De Luca E, Notarnicola M, Ali FM, Žilinskas J, Strupas K, Kondrotas P, Baltrunas R, Kutkevicius J, Ignatavicius P, Tan CL, Siaw JY, Yam SY, Wilson L, Aziz MRA, Bondin J, Zorrilla CD, Majbar A, Sale D, Abdullahi L, Osagie O, Faboya O, Fatuga A, Taiwo A, Nwabuoku E, Bliksøen M, Khan ZA, Coronel J, Miranda C, Vasquez I, Helguero-Santin LM, Rickard J, Mironescu A, Adedeji A, Alqahtani S, Rath M, Van Niekerk M, Koto MZ, Matos-Puig R, Israelsson L, Schuetz T, Yuksek MA, Mericliler M, Uluşahin M, Wolf B, Fairfield C, Yong GL, Whitehurst K, Wilson M, Redgrave N, Musyoka CK, Olivier J, Lee K, Cox M, Farhan-Alanie MMH, Callan R, Chibuye C, Ali THA, Rekhis S, Rommaneh M, Halhouli O, Sam ZH, Chen JHC, Roi D, Ismaïl L, Kalles V, Pata F, Nita GE, Coccolini F, Ansaloni L, Pugliesi TB, Pardo G, Blanco R, Escobar EG.. - In: BJS OPEN. - ISSN 2474-9842. - ELETTRONICO. - (2019), pp. 403-414. [10.1002/bjs5.50138]
Global variation in anastomosis and end colostomy formation following left-sided colorectal resection.
Ringressi MN;Taddei AMembro del Collaboration Group
;
2019
Abstract
Background: End colostomy rates following colorectal resection vary across institutions in high-income settings, being influenced by patient, disease, surgeon and system factors. This study aimed to assess global variation in end colostomy rates after left-sided colorectal resection. Methods: This study comprised an analysis of GlobalSurg-1 and -2 international, prospective, observational cohort studies (2014, 2016), including consecutive adult patients undergoing elective or emergency left-sided colorectal resection within discrete 2-week windows. Countries were grouped into high-, middle- and low-income tertiles according to the United Nations Human Development Index (HDI). Factors associated with colostomy formation versus primary anastomosis were explored using a multilevel, multivariable logistic regression model. Results: In total, 1635 patients from 242 hospitals in 57 countries undergoing left-sided colorectal resection were included: 113 (6·9 per cent) from low-HDI, 254 (15·5 per cent) from middle-HDI and 1268 (77·6 per cent) from high-HDI countries. There was a higher proportion of patients with perforated disease (57·5, 40·9 and 35·4 per cent; P < 0·001) and subsequent use of end colostomy (52·2, 24·8 and 18·9 per cent; P < 0·001) in low- compared with middle- and high-HDI settings. The association with colostomy use in low-HDI settings persisted (odds ratio (OR) 3·20, 95 per cent c.i. 1·35 to 7·57; P = 0·008) after risk adjustment for malignant disease (OR 2·34, 1·65 to 3·32; P < 0·001), emergency surgery (OR 4·08, 2·73 to 6·10; P < 0·001), time to operation at least 48 h (OR 1·99, 1·28 to 3·09; P = 0·002) and disease perforation (OR 4·00, 2·81 to 5·69; P < 0·001). Conclusion: Global differences existed in the proportion of patients receiving end stomas after left-sided colorectal resection based on income, which went beyond case mix alone.
| File | Dimensione | Formato | |
|---|---|---|---|
|
BJS5-3-403.pdf
accesso aperto
Tipologia:
Pdf editoriale (Version of record)
Licenza:
Open Access
Dimensione
543.27 kB
Formato
Adobe PDF
|
543.27 kB | Adobe PDF |
I documenti in FLORE sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.
