Topological phase diagram of optimally shaken honeycomb lattices: A dual perspective from stroboscopic and non stroboscopic Floquet Hamiltonians

We present a direct comparison between the stroboscopic and nonstroboscopic effective approaches for ultracold atoms in shaken honeycomb lattices, focusing specifically on the optimal driving introduced by A. Verdeny and F. Mintert [Phys. Rev. A 92, 063615 (2015)]. In the fast-driving regime, we compare the effective nonstroboscopic Hamiltonian derived through a perturbative expansion with a nonperturbative calculation of the stroboscopic Floquet Hamiltonian, obtained through a direct numerical approach. We find that the leading off-diagonal tunneling coefficients, which define the undriven model, retain their isotropic nature under the effect of the driving, and their values are independent of the computational approach used. This consistency ensures the robustness of certain topological properties, such as the position of Dirac points, as expected. Conversely, the next-to-leading diagonal tunneling coefficients, generated dynamically, can vary across different approaches without affecting the system topology. This suggests that the topological phase diagram is most conveniently represented in terms of the physical parameters characterizing the driving and directly accessible in experiments, rather than in terms of the tunneling parameters.