The authority of the past was neither self-evident nor uncontested in early modern political thought. Ancient historians offered examples through which rulers and their critics sought to understand the present, yet their lessons depended upon changing circumstances, competing interpretations and the purposes of those who invoked them. This essay traces the tensions between historical precedent and political experience from Renaissance Florence to the eighteenth-century Atlantic world. Beginning with Machiavelli and Guicciardini, it examines how the authority of classical history was negotiated and reconfigured, particularly through the reception of Tacitus and Sallust. In the writings of Thomas Gordon, historical translation and political commentary became closely intertwined, while the defence of the governed’s capacity to judge their governors challenged established claims to political authority. The essay concludes with an appeal published under the name ‘CATO’ in Pennsylvania in 1781, when an inherited classical vocabulary was enlisted in defence of Black freedom against the threat of renewed enslavement.
Who Speaks for the Past? History and Political Authority in the Early Modern World / Tarantino, G.. - In: CROMOHS. - ISSN 1123-7023. - ELETTRONICO. - 30:(2026), pp. 0-0.
Who Speaks for the Past? History and Political Authority in the Early Modern World
Tarantino, Giovanni
2026
Abstract
The authority of the past was neither self-evident nor uncontested in early modern political thought. Ancient historians offered examples through which rulers and their critics sought to understand the present, yet their lessons depended upon changing circumstances, competing interpretations and the purposes of those who invoked them. This essay traces the tensions between historical precedent and political experience from Renaissance Florence to the eighteenth-century Atlantic world. Beginning with Machiavelli and Guicciardini, it examines how the authority of classical history was negotiated and reconfigured, particularly through the reception of Tacitus and Sallust. In the writings of Thomas Gordon, historical translation and political commentary became closely intertwined, while the defence of the governed’s capacity to judge their governors challenged established claims to political authority. The essay concludes with an appeal published under the name ‘CATO’ in Pennsylvania in 1781, when an inherited classical vocabulary was enlisted in defence of Black freedom against the threat of renewed enslavement.I documenti in FLORE sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.



