Comparison between Post Hartree-Fock and DFT Methods for the Study of Strength and Mechanism of Cleavage of Hg-C

A parallel MP2 and DFT study was performed for mercury dihalides and for representative organomercury compounds including a Hg(SINGLE BOND)C bond. From a methodological point of view, medium-size basis sets provide reliable general trends for a number of properties already at the HF level. However, quantitative results can only be obtained including correlation energy by post-Hartree-Fock (even at the MP2 level) or density functional models and adding f-polarization functions on Hg. At this level, geometrical parameters are sufficiently accurate for most purposes and reliable thermodynamic data can be obtained using isodesmic reactions. The advantage of the DF approach resides, besides the shorter computation times, in the lower dependence of the results on the basis set. From a more general point of view, all the computations indicate that Hg(SINGLE BOND)C bond breaking is favored, decreasing the electronegativity of further substituents. We have next investigated the reaction mechanism for cleavage of the Hg(SINGLE BOND)C bond by halogenic acids. Our results show that the reaction occurs through a one-step mechanism in which, however, bond forming and breaking are not completely synchronous.