Experimental and simulation study of harmonic components generated by plane and focused waves

Although there is increasing interest in the use of plane waves (PW) in high-frame-rate imaging, not much experimental data is available about their behavior in terms of nonlinear propagation. This paper presents a detailed study of fundamental and harmonic components of the ultrasound beam associated to PW transmission from a linear array. Simulations and hydrophone measurements of PW propagation in water were performed and compared to the results obtained for focused waves (FWs) at various levels of peak negative pressure (PNP). Experimental results confirm that, at comparable PNP, the amplitudes of the harmonics reached by PWs are always higher, over extended regions, than those achieved with FW. For example, at MI = 0.2 the PW second harmonic turns out to be 9 dB higher at 25 mm depth (i.e. in the focal region), and 20 dB higher at 40 mm depth. Simulations additionally show that when ultrasound waves propagate through blood or muscle, the situation is in general reversed but, at low MI, the second harmonic amplitude can still be higher in PW than in FW. Furthermore, it is shown that increasing the array aperture size yields higher harmonic growth in PW compared to FW.